Thursday, November 19, 2026
News

Policy cannot come at the cost of citizens: Karnataka Minister Rizwan Arshad writes to Hardeep Puri over E20 concerns

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend    Print this Page   COMMENT

Bengaluru (Karnataka) | November 19, 2026 9:11:24 AM IST
Karnataka Food Minister Rizwan Arshad has written to Union Minister for Petroleum and Natural Gas Hardeep Singh Puri, flagging findings from the State's fuel quality tests and seeking urgent corrective measures in the implementation of the Ethanol Blending Programme.

In his letter on "Karnataka's Fuel Test Findings and Steps to Protect the Common Man", Arshad clarified that the State government was not opposed to the Ethanol Blending Programme but had concerns over excessive ethanol blending in petrol.

"The programme cannot come at the cost of the citizens. A transition of this scale needs the whole ecosystem to be ready, including fuel infrastructure and ethanol-compliant vehicles, and that transition takes time," Arshad said.

Arshad said over the past several months, the State received a very large number of complaints from motorists across Karnataka. People reported falling mileage, rough running of engines, damage to older vehicles, and receiving less fuel than they paid for.

"When so many ordinary citizens raise the same concern, no government can afford to look away," he said, adding that the State undertook verification of both the quality and quantity of petrol through officers empowered under law.

The Centre, through Notification S.O. 860(E) dated February 17, 2026, which came into force on April 1, 2026, directed oil marketing companies (OMCs) to sell ethanol-blended motor spirit containing 20 per cent ethanol in accordance with Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS) specifications.

In September 2026, State officials inspected 63 retail outlets across various districts, covering outlets operated by Indian Oil Corporation Limited (IOCL), Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited (BPCL), Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited (HPCL) and Mangalore Refinery and Petrochemicals Limited (MRPL).

The samples were sent through the OMCs' State Level Coordinator to designated laboratories of the three public sector oil marketing companies. However, of the 63 samples collected, only 42 test reports had been received, and none of them mentioned the percentage of ethanol content.

When questioned, the State was told that Research Octane Number (RON) is the parameter for compliance. However, Arshad said the OMCs' own reply acknowledges that IS 17021 mandates measurement of ethanol content, yet no such measurement was carried out.

"This is a clear admission of non-compliance with the very standard they cite. A report that is silent on ethanol therefore cannot certify compliance with an E20 mandate.Reports for the remaining 21 samples are yet to be received, with no reason given for the delay," the Minister said.

"Dissatisfied, the State drew fresh samples and sent them to independent NABL-accredited laboratories. Of the 14 samples tested, 11 were found to contain more than 20 per cent ethanol, with the highest at over 31 per cent," he said.

Arshad rejected OMCs' allegations that samples were not collected as per prescribed procedure. He said every sample was drawn by officers duly authorised under the Motor Spirit and High Speed Diesel (Regulation of Supply, Distribution and Prevention of Malpractices) Order, 2005, strictly in accordance with clause 8.

He added that counterpart samples were sealed and handed over at the spot, while the densities recorded at the time of collection matched those mentioned in the laboratory reports.

"The OMCs kept back the one fact consumers needed to know, and they are now trying to discredit independent, accredited findings instead of answering them. This is not a technical objection. It is an attempt to avoid accountability," Arshad said.

The Minister further flagged variations in ethanol content across the samples, stating that the percentage ranged from 13.5 per cent to 31.2 per cent, against the notified 20 per cent blend.

"Such wide variations leave the consumer wholly unaware of the composition of the fuel being dispensed into their vehicle," he said.

He added that premium high-speed petrol, sold at nearly Rs 120 to Rs 140 per litre and marketed as superior fuel, was also found to carry a high ethanol percentage.

"The common man, practically, is left with no real option," he said.

Arshad said inspections have created deterrence and there are indications the blend may since have been corrected, but Karnataka will continue to check fuel quality on a continuous basis.

On quantity, Arshad said two recent Central notifications have weakened safeguards.Notification G.S.R. 905(E) dated December 18, 2025 doubles the mandatory verification interval for petrol and diesel dispensers from 12 months to 24 months and notification G.S.R. 346(E) dated May 8, 2026 amends rules governing Government Approved Test Centres, allowing private test centres to verify dispensers, a function so far performed by government inspectors.

Arshad said that before these notifications were adopted, Karnataka's Department of Legal Metrology had conducted a statewide inspection survey, which he described as the first such study undertaken by any State.

Of the 5,946 retail outlets in Karnataka, 805 were inspected, and 768, nearly nine out of every ten outlets, required recalibration. Of the 3,071 nozzles tested, 2,618 showed deviations from their rated accuracy.

A total of 101 outlets were found dispensing fuel beyond the maximum permissible error and were booked, with fines amounting to Rs 6.66 lakh collected. The Minister further noted that even nozzles operating within permissible limits were approaching the tolerance threshold within just nine to 11 months of use.

"These findings show that the existing annual cycle is itself barely adequate. A 24-month cycle would leave a large share of dispensers delivering short measures long before their next mandated check," Arshad said.

"The State has therefore decided not to implement either notification and will continue annual verification through government inspectors. The State has also written to Union Consumer Affairs Minister Pralhad Joshi seeking reconsideration of both notifications," he said.

Arshad also placed five demands before the Centre to address concerns related to fuel quality, transparency and consumer protection.

The first demand was to ensure the prominent display of the actual ethanol blend at every petrol pump, with the ethanol percentage of each grade of petrol clearly mentioned at retail outlets.

The second demand was to make it mandatory for petrol pumps to mention the ethanol percentage on every bill or receipt issued to consumers.

Third, he sought the availability of lower-blend E10 petrol and ethanol-free petrol alongside E20, at affordable prices, until the country's vehicle fleet becomes fully compatible with higher ethanol blends.

Fourth, he called for an independent testing mechanism involving random third-party checks through NABL-accredited laboratories with no stake in the outcome. He also demanded that every test report clearly mention the ethanol content.

The fifth demand was the creation of a dedicated E20 compensation fund to compensate consumers whose vehicles suffer damage due to petrol containing ethanol above the prescribed limit. He proposed that claims be settled through a simple and time-bound process based on certification from authorised service centres.

"The findings clearly indicate that the E20 policy, as it is being implemented today, requires urgent course correction. A policy of this scale can succeed only if the common man is placed at its centre, not made to bear its cost," Arshad said.

The Minister urged Puri to review the implementation of the E20 programme in light of the State's findings and in consultation with the States. He also expressed willingness to participate in a detailed discussion on the matter at the earliest.(ANI)

 
  LATEST COMMENTS ()
POST YOUR COMMENT
Comments Not Available
 
POST YOUR COMMENT
 
 
TRENDING TOPICS
 
 
CITY NEWS
MORE CITIES
 
 
INDIA WORLD ASIA
Himachal CM Sukhu expresses grief over d...
Policy cannot come at the cost of citize...
'Happy Birthday, tigress!': Priyanka Gan...
Pensions and sarees on Constitution Day:...
Punjab: Bridge over Bhakra Canal collaps...
New Delhi: Parliamentary committees to e...
More...    
 
 Top Stories
ANSR Named a Leader in Everest Grou... 
Taylor Swift returns to CMA Awards ... 
Worst of US trade friction likely b... 
MS Dhoni's 19-year IPL journey: Ico... 
“Game follows criminal duo”: Congre... 
1st Test: Nicholls' ton, Phillips' ... 
Ravi Somani Unveils His Book ‘Four ... 
MP: 2 die, 5 fall ill after consumi...