Saturday, November 21, 2026
News

Delhi HC quashes defamation case against Pinaki Misra, says no evidence of reputational harm

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend    Print this Page   COMMENT

New Delhi | November 21, 2026 4:11:22 PM IST
The Delhi High Court has quashed criminal defamation proceedings against Senior Advocate and former MP Pinaki Misra over his alleged remark describing a lawyer as a crook, observing that there was no material to establish that the alleged statement had lowered the complainants reputation in the estimation of others.

Justice Sachin Datta set aside the trial courts April 20, 2019 summoning order and quashed the defamation complaint along with all proceedings arising from it.

The court noted that the complainant, a practising advocate, had examined only himself as a witness during the pre-summoning evidence and had not produced any other person to establish that his reputation was lowered because of the alleged remark.

Referring to Explanation 4 to Section 499 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC), the court observed that an imputation can be considered harmful to a persons reputation only when it directly or indirectly lowers that persons standing in the estimation of others.

The High Court relied on a judgment passed by a coordinate bench on August 25, 2026, which had quashed another defamation complaint filed by the same lawyer against Misra over a separate online news publication arising out of the same controversy.

In that case, the court had held that the complainants allegation of reputational damage was based solely on his own statement, without any independent material to demonstrate that the alleged imputation had lowered his reputation in the eyes of others.

The present case arose from an Economic Times report published on August 27, 2018, concerning a complaint lodged by the lawyer before the Bar Council of Delhi alleging professional misconduct against Misra on the ground of conflict of interest.

At the relevant time, Misra was a Lok Sabha MP and Chairperson of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Urban Development. He had appeared before the National Green Tribunal (NGT) on behalf of certain power distribution companies in a matter concerning e-waste management.

The complainant, who was appearing for the applicant in the NGT proceedings, had objected to Misras appearance, contending that the parliamentary committee chaired by him had made adverse recommendations against the power distribution companies on the same issue.

He subsequently approached the Bar Council of Delhi, alleging professional misconduct on account of a conflict of interest.

The newspaper report carried the complainants allegations and quoted Misra as describing him as a crook. The lawyer subsequently sent a legal notice to Misra on August 31, 2018, seeking an unconditional apology.

The Bar Council of Delhi dismissed the professional misconduct complaint on November 16, 2018. Thereafter, the lawyer filed a criminal defamation complaint under Sections 499 and 500 of the IPC.

The trial court took cognisance of the complaint on January 15, 2019, and summoned Misra on April 20, 2019. Misra challenged the summoning order before the High Court, which stayed its operation in May 2019.

Justice Datta observed that the complainant had neither identified anyone who had read the newspaper report nor examined any person to establish that his reputation had been lowered in their estimation.

The court also referred to the complainants failure to appear in the proceedings despite several opportunities being granted to him to address arguments. It, however, considered his counter-affidavit, which reiterated the allegations of conflict of interest and claimed that the publication had damaged his reputation.

The High Court further observed that the trial courts summoning order did not consider the context in which the alleged words were used or the dismissal of the complaint by the Bar Council of Delhi.

What particularly weighs with the Court is the fact that the summoning order in the connected complaint on the same controversy has already been set aside on grounds identical to those urged in the present petition, the court observed.

Allowing Misras petition, the High Court set aside the April 20, 2019 summoning order and quashed the criminal defamation complaint and all proceedings emanating from it. The judgment was pronounced on November 17, 2026. (ANI)

 
  LATEST COMMENTS ()
POST YOUR COMMENT
Comments Not Available
 
POST YOUR COMMENT
 
 
TRENDING TOPICS
 
 
CITY NEWS
MORE CITIES
 
 
INDIA WORLD ASIA
India crosses historic milestone of 1 cr...
Karnataka CM DK Shivakumar to lead high-...
Gujarat Dy CM Harsh Sanghavi attends Ta...
Delhi wakes up to another morning of 'po...
Home Minister Amit Shah arrives in Aruna...
Odisha: Mayurbhanj, Balasore placed in r...
More...    
 
 Top Stories
Monumental Painting of Krishna Debu... 
Running an organisation with discip... 
Maharashtra CM Fadnavis launches 'C... 
Gold, silver prices plunge; Jewelle... 
Overhead Equipment energised on 50-... 
StarAgri signs agreement with IDBI ... 
"Real issue is people of UP, not fo... 
"In his opposition to PM Modi, Rahu...