Thursday, August 22, 2019
News

ICJ threw out 3 objections by Pakistan to admissibility of India's plea

   SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend    Print this Page   COMMENT

The Hague | Thursday, 2019 6:15:05 AM IST
The International Court of Justice (ICJ) while ruling in favour of India threw out three objections raised by Pakistan on admissibility of India's application against the death sentence awarded to Kulbhushan Jadhav by a Pakistani military court.

India moved the ICJ on May 8, 2017 after a Pakistani military court sentenced Jadhav to death for alleged espionage.

The world court said the dispute was related to the "interpretation and application of the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations". The ICJ said it has "jurisdiction under Article I of Optional Protocol to Vienna Convention on Consular Relations concerning the Compulsory Settlement of Disputes".

The first objection of Pakistan to the admissibility of India's application was on "alleged abuse of process". The court observed that there was "no basis to conclude that India abused its procedural rights when it requested indication of provisional measures -- Articles II and III of Optional Protocol do not contain preconditions to the Court's exercise of its jurisdiction."

The second objection was on "alleged abuse of rights" and Pakistan's "contention that India failed to prove Jadhav's nationality". The ICJ said there was "no room for doubt that Mr. Jadhav is of Indian nationality".

The other arguments advanced by Pakistan "based on alleged breaches of India's international obligations under Security Council resolution 1373 (2001)" were also rejected.

The third objection of Pakistan was on "India's alleged unlawful conduct". The court said Pakistan's objection based on "clean hands" doctrine (a rule of law that a person coming to court with a lawsuit or petition for a court order must be free from unfair conduct) was rejected.

It said there was "no explanation on how alleged unlawful conduct by India prevented Pakistan from providing consular access to Jadhav.

Pakistan's objection based on the principle of "ex turpi causa non oritur actio" (that no action can arise from an illegal act) cannot be upheld, the ICJ said.

The principle "ex injuria jus non oritur" (law or right does not arise from injustice) implies that "unjust acts cannot create law" is inapposite in the present case, the court said while throwing out Pakistan's third objection to admissibility of India's petition.

--IANS rn/arm

( 375 Words)

2019-07-18-00:00:07 (IANS)

 
  LATEST COMMENTS (0)
POST YOUR COMMENT
Comments Not Available
 
POST YOUR COMMENT
 
 
TRENDING TOPICS
 
 
CITY NEWS
MORE CITIES
 
 
 
MORE ASIA NEWS
Decks clear for limiting river flow to P...
Bangladesh urged to halt returning Rohin...
Pakistan opposition accuses government o...
'Pakistan to continue raising Kashmir is...
3 reviews to determine Pak's place on FA...
Kashmir India's internal matter: US Defe...
More...
 
INDIA WORLD ASIA
Row over Jagan's 'refusal' to light lamp...
Not hiding from law, says Chidambaram at...
Yamuna continues to flow above danger ma...
Arsalan story twist: Elder brother was d...
After ED, CBI issues lookout circular ag...
Rajiv@75: Sonia Gandhi to address politi...
More...    
 
 Top Stories
WTC is going to take standard of cr... 
West Indies Team upbeat for the cha... 
Karnataka preparing policy to regul... 
Fifth India-Nepal Joint Commission ... 
Etawah ragging case: Preliminary in... 
LFW 2019: Pandya, Haydon walk for A... 
eBIZ MD, son arrested for Rs 5,000 ... 
Abdalla Hamdok takes charge as Suda...